A boy or girl who comes from a hunting family has already spent more mornings in the woods than most adults will in a lifetime. My grandkids have walked in the woods with their dads and me since they could keep up, learning the difference between a doe track and a buck track in the alluvial soil of the Mississippi Delta, and sat still long enough to watch a deer step out into the open. Those memories will be as priceless for them as they are for us.
Three decades from now, they could be sitting in a shooting house on that same food plot filled with memories with their children, desperately hoping to see a deer. They will sit near where the old scrape used to be, and they will listen for the crunch of the leaves. Hours will pass, and once again, nothing. They will look at their children and try to explain why families who hunted these woods for generations can now sit all morning without seeing a deer, and why the place that once held so many deer now holds mostly silence.
Their children will not understand the word prevalence. They will only know the woods their mom or dad hunted in with their dad are not the same woods they are sitting in now. As they get older, they will wonder how talking about a disease that kills deer became so difficult back then for so many hunters and hunting-industry personalities and leaders who could have said more and made a bigger difference. “Why did so many choose to stay quiet?”
Benton County is the preview
In places like Benton County, we are starting to see what Mississippi’s future might look like. Statewide CWD prevalence sits near 1.5 percent. In Benton County, it has climbed above 25 percent. Hunters there report fewer deer, and it took a long time to get here. It shows up first as fewer tracks and fewer mature bucks in the places the disease has been longest.
Science has indisputably proved that CWD kills deer. Most of them look fine for a long time while they are spreading the disease. As the disease builds up, the herd thins, and mature bucks become few and far between. That has already happened in hotspots across America where researchers have tracked numbers long enough to see the pattern.
There is no cure for CWD. Once prevalence climbs, the prions stay in the soil for years. That is why the best time to limit new introductions is before the landscape itself becomes a reservoir for the disease. Only more testing, more harvesting to manage deer numbers, keeping carcasses from carrying it to new ground, and limiting artificial congregation and the transporting of live deer can slow it.
Simple steps most of us can take
For most of us, the practical steps to help slow the spread of CWD are simpler than the arguments. Submit the head for testing, especially if you hunt in or near a CWD management zone. Don’t move whole carcasses out of those zones. Stop supplemental feeding and baiting where it’s banned. And where deer numbers are high, harvest the deer the biologists are asking for.
None of these steps feel dramatic. Right? Together, they reduce the animals that can carry and shed the disease and limit where it concentrates.
For most places, CWD isn’t a burning platform. It takes a long time to establish itself in the landscape. The last thing we should do is inject it into places that are currently CWD-free. That seems practical and doable for a growing number of hunters.
Healthy deer are good for the people who hunt them and the companies that sell hunting equipment, feed, seeds, fertilizer, hunting grounds, and so much more. It’s a multi-billion-dollar industry in America. In Mississippi alone, the MSU Deer Lab just completed a detailed study and found that whitetail deer have a billion-dollar economic impact.
A long-term drop in mature bucks and overall deer numbers hurts that entire economy. What we are learning from the high-prevalence counties across America is alarming. Anyone with their head on straight who looks at those numbers and listens to landowners talk about what they are seeing on the ground in those places can’t conclude anything other than, let’s do what we can to slow the spread. Sadly, that’s our only tool.
Why staying quiet still pays
So why is it so hard for hunters to agree on the basic steps that could protect the deer landscape for as long as possible? Part of it is the pressure of a calendar that leads so much unsaid, thus too many hunters are left believing there’s nothing to be concerned about.
Let me explain.
Outdoor/hunting-industry CEOs are measured quarter by quarter. Their job is shareholder value this quarter. A painfully slow-spreading fatal deer disease like CWD that will likely shrink the customer base a generation from now, combined with a confused and divided customer base that has been overwhelmed with misinformation that has left some customers comparing CWD to COVID, makes acting on —even acknowledging— the disease risky. It is an almost impossible assignment for a current CEO when the only score that counts is the one at the end of the current reporting period.
Supporting tighter rules, or even speaking plainly about the disease, risks immediate pushback. Missteps by those involved in the CWD conversation over the years have contributed to the confusion. So, staying quiet avoids the noise. That approach and the business math work in the short term, even when it works against the product that will still need to exist when our great-grandkids are old enough to hunt.
The confusion is not mainly a lack of information. The disease moves slowly enough that most hunters still see plenty of deer. At the same time, the biggest influencers push agendas for groups like deer breeders and high-fence commercial hunting operations, focus on short-term financial and social-media numbers and sponsorships, and cater to customers who want to believe them.
The result is a steady stream of “it’s overblown” and “CWD doesn’t kill deer.” And there’s a continued silence from a growing number of others who know better. Too many hunters still think the science must be unsettled. It isn’t. The disagreement is mostly about timing and who pays the short-term cost.
Steve Rinella, host of the MeatEater podcast and a longtime voice in the outdoor community, put it plainly. “In my view, we’ve hit a dangerous spot around conversations about chronic wasting disease because we’ve had a lot of guys hit the done phase. They’re done. I don’t think we should be done.” He has also acknowledged the disease is slow and cryptic, that there is still no reliable live-animal test, and that while no human has been shown to have contracted a prion disease from eating deer meat, “there’s always a possibility… Right now this whole thing is shrouded in question marks. It makes people nervous. Let’s learn more. Let’s study it.”
The voices who know better
As I said, too many influential outdoor personalities say the disease is overblown, a hoax, or not worth the trouble. Even more importantly, a growing number of others who know better stay silent. A fair number of the popular and influential quiet ones sit on the payrolls of the same companies that answer to quarterly numbers. Speaking up carries risk. Saying nothing does not. Together, they leave most of the airtime and influence to misinformation, confusion, and delay.
Hunting industry leaders don’t lack information. They see the same studies and state reports we do. It’s been extraordinarily well documented that as CWD prevalence climbs, survival falls. Deer densities drop in the places that have lived with the disease long enough to measure the decline. It’s literally indisputable. They know it is real. The question is what they do with that knowledge when the next quarter’s numbers, the next sponsorship, or the next customer complaint is sitting in front of them.
Those who know the truth and don’t use their platforms to share it likely lose sleep at night because they know their legacies will be tarnished.
Will Primos built one of the outdoor industry’s most respected hunting brands by focusing on what works over the long haul. He has spent years talking to people about the science behind CWD. “I have spoken to all who would listen,” he said, “but many have not yet felt what will happen if we keep putting this off.” He has seen it with his own eyes, and he is not ambiguous about what comes next. “Those of you who are in charge have an opportunity to practice the discipline that got you to where you are today. After all, discipline is giving up what you want now for what you really want later. Do the right thing.”
The question your great-grandchildren will ask
There is a better way. Why can’t we all get on the same page and work together to control this disease? It seems so obvious that we should. The voices that shape hunting today will likely not be the ones standing on that ridge thirty years from now. Those children will not care who hit their numbers this quarter. They will only know whether the woods still hold a deer worth waiting for.
Success is not eradicating CWD. I wish it were. As I say, we should pray science catches up, but until then, we must focus on keeping prevalence as low as possible, and new introductions rare enough so that thirty years from now there is still a deer worth waiting for on that ridge.
When your great-grandchildren look up and ask why they didn’t see a deer, what will your legacy say you did? And does that even matter to you? I hope it does.
Please join Will Primos, Steve Renella, me, hundreds, if not thousands, of biologists and researchers, and a growing number of hunters who care and want to make a difference for our kids and our kids’ kids. We can do this if we work together.
The views expressed by contributors are their own and not the views of SuperTalk Mississippi Media.

